So will it be Spies or Haga?

Discussion in 'Motorcycle Racing' started by PaulpULVITZKA, Oct 6, 2009.

  1. Last 2 races, all up in the air, who is NOT going to crack under
    pressure?

    Gut feeling those few points that Fabrizio took off Haga are really
    going to count now.

    I want Haga to win, but feel Spies will, and to be honest he deserves
    it, best rider of the year, with Simoncelli 2nd best.

    Least we now have ONE good rider in MotoGP for 2010 [Hint hayden, TAKE
    A HIKE!]
     
    PaulpULVITZKA, Oct 6, 2009
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. PaulpULVITZKA

    Andrew Guest

    Man are you delusional.
    Simoncelli is/was the 2nd best rider this year in WSBK?
    You just got through saying you want Haga to win, wouldn't you think if he
    doesn't he would be the 2nd best rider in SBK this year?
     
    Andrew, Oct 6, 2009
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. PaulpULVITZKA

    pablo Guest

    Simoncelli - a one off, on his total home circuit he has every
    obligation to know inside and out? Heck no. Have him ride a superbike
    on a more obscure circuit and win a race, and *then* we can talk about
    the merit of his accomplishment. What he did was.. neat. And no less
    than should be expected of him, in my opinion.

    As to the main question, heck, roll the dice. It is goig to be a
    battle of nerves and poise. To me , the riding skill and poise
    equation goes to Spies. Natural poker player. The WSB experience and
    familiarity card (not inconsiderable) goes to Haga. I like Haga. Then
    again, he's had so many chances that I actually would like the shock
    and surprise of Spies winning it. And in turn the total surprise
    factor of him shaking up GP next year. One can dream. I don't like the
    predictable. I prefer the memorable.
     
    pablo, Oct 6, 2009
    #3
  4. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    I think we've got a re-run of Imola 2002. Spies will take pole and win
    the first race and then the championship will be decided by whoever wins
    the second. With Fabrizio playing the Xaus role and Biaggi and Rea
    getting in the way. Perhaps Ducati should give a 3rd factory bike to
    Byrne in the hope that he gets in the mix as well?

    I said at the beginning of the year that Haga would find a way to lose
    it. I hope it's not just 2 close second places that turn out to be just
    not quite enough.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 6, 2009
    #4
  5. PaulpULVITZKA

    Bruce Guest

    somewhat true - track knowledge etc., but I bet many 250 riders that
    know that track couldn't have done that well on a superbike. I am
    looking forward to see what he can do in MotoGP (Although that class is
    losing it's luster to me, it has become way to much of a machine/luck
    class, many boring races, and many good riders that just don't have the
    equipment to to really compete.

    Bruce
     
    Bruce, Oct 6, 2009
    #5
  6. SO WHAT'S haydens EXCUSE THEN?

    :)
     
    PaulpULVITZKA, Oct 6, 2009
    #6
  7. I never said Haga was the 2nd best rider or even that good, just that
    he has a very good chance of winning the Championship, he [Haga] has
    pretty much arsed his way through the season till Spies got into his
    strides, the Ducati is still the best overall bike in the field that
    has helped him no end [Till Aprilia get a decent full-time rider]

    Be that as it may, it's still a good effort, say compared to Hodgsons
    "Championship" win on the Ducati...lol

    About as worthy of a Championship as hayden.
     
    PaulpULVITZKA, Oct 6, 2009
    #7
  8. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    I think maybe I read that backwards. But did Haga land on his arse at
    Donington?
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 6, 2009
    #8
  9. Me too.

    His effort in the single SBK race was outstanding.

    That he had some crashes [which more often than not means your pushing
    hard] and machinery failures in the 250's he should have been W/
    Champion again this year....Still a chance all the same.

    If he does well and beats all the other privates in the MotoGP/2010
    and mixes it with the "A" graders, his option for 2011 will be factory
    Ducati with Stoner, in place of hopeless hayden [hooray she cried!] OR
    haonda might put him into the Repsol factory team, either Divz. or
    Pedbot are riding for their future in 2010 and one will have to go.

    Expecting BIG things from Simoncelli and Spies in 2010.
     
    PaulpULVITZKA, Oct 6, 2009
    #9
  10. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    You can think whatever you like. And you probably will.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 8, 2009
    #10
  11. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    What are you on about? You mean the track where Spies and Rea were on
    the front row and Spies lost out on pole by a fraction. On those high
    production, low cost R1/Blades.
    Hairpins and chicanes, mate, hairpins and chicanes. Biaggi runs a
    fraction wide and invites him in, Simoncelli really wants to beat Biaggi
    (after the TXT from Rossi). Simoncelli is a racer. And you really want
    him to not go for the gap? And all this is unfolding in front of Spies
    but it's Marco's fault for Spies being run onto the grass by Biaggi?
    Perhaps you need reminding that nobody actually touched in that whole
    incident.

    No. The real problem there wasn't Marco, it was the damn stupid slow
    chicane.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 8, 2009
    #11
  12. PaulpULVITZKA

    Dirt Guest

    My heart wants Spies to win, but my head is telling me it'll likely be
    Haga. Haga's been good enough the past few races I find it unlikely
    Spies will be able to beat him twice in Portugal. Still, Spies' has
    done this before against Mladin. Anything is possible. Perhaps
    Biaggi would be kind enough to barg Haga off the track once to make
    things even... ;)
     
    Dirt, Oct 8, 2009
    #12
  13. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    Well, Mark was having his usual dig at Ducati and now Aprilia for racing
    an unavailable prototype in an apparently production based formula. But
    really at WSB level they're all prototypes now. You can't buy a Xerox
    Ducati any more than you can buy a Yamaha Italia R1 or a Ten Kate Blade.
    So trying to put a figure on what they cost is a bit meaningless. But I
    was being simpler. If the track suits the unobtainable Ducati and
    Aprilia so well, how come a Blade and R1 were also on the front row? I
    really didn't see a lot of difference in overall bike performance
    although they did have different strengths. Pretty much like every other
    race this year.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 8, 2009
    #13
  14. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    Because of the continual upgrades? At one point I quite fancied a
    Superduke but then they went and improved it considerably. Quite fancied
    the Street Triple too, except that then they did the R with everything
    sorted that they should have done first. It's a bitch when you buy
    something only for next year's model to be that much better[1].
    Thankfully the recession seems to have put paid to that. No updates till
    2011. Hooray!

    [1] Well with more bling, anyway.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 8, 2009
    #14
  15. PaulpULVITZKA

    Mark N Guest

    C'mon, Julian, you can't be serious. Ducatis and Aprilias filled both
    podiums, and the top four in the race where Simoncelli didn't crash
    out. Spies managed to stay within 5.5 seconds in the first race, but
    was nearly 15 seconds back in the second (not helped by Simoncelli, to
    be sure). And the 2nd-best of the true production bikes, both Hondas,
    were 14.5 and 16.4 seconds back, 0.7-0.8 second per lap. For Ducati
    Corse it was their 2nd-best score of the season, 86 out of a possible
    90 (which they scored at Kyalami), and for Aprilia it was their 3rd-
    best day, behind Losail and Brno (Biaggi's best track, and aided by
    the Spies-Fab incident); had Simoncelli not crashed it would have
    easily been their best. And Fabrizio did take pole; that Spies and Rea
    bested Haga on a one-lap banzai on qualifiers really means nothing.

    As for the machines, there is a material difference between the bikes.
    The Japanese machines and the BMW are true production bikes, built in
    significant numbers and to a meaningful extent to be affordable and
    usable on the street. That they are all inline fours is probably in
    part a cost consideration. The Ducati and Aprilia are built in limited
    numbers, at a relatively high price, and are really intended more for
    racing than street riding, and specifically as superbike foundations.
    When WSB made the new homologation requirement 1000 machines for 2008
    and 2009 with an increase to 3000 in 2010, they weren't doing the
    stair-step for the Japanese, who were unquestionably above 3000 all
    the time, and probably not BMW. They were doing it for Ducati and
    Aprilia; I don't know specific production numbers, but I have heard
    1500 for both machines. So you put these machines on a big-time
    acceleration track like Imola and they have an edge, not much
    question.
    Even Marco admitted to screwing up there after the race, but said "it
    turned out all right", which of course is only from his perspective.
    Newsflash, Julian - there is always an opening on the inside going ito
    a corner, no one runs right on the inside curbing going in. The issue
    is always how much of an opening there is, how far back the trailing
    rider is, and can he get by cleanly. In this case Marco couldn't, and
    that Max ran off track in order to avoid being hit by Marco and there
    was no contact doesn't excuse Marco at all, nor does the fact that Max
    was then stuck getting in Ben's way and forcing him to also go off-
    track to avoid a collision somehow excuse Marco. No, it was all his
    fault, and it was the usual contemporary and sleazy maneuver that has
    plagued GP racing for at least a generation. I mean, how many times
    did Hayden have to go wide on Sunday to avoid being hit from up the
    inside? This year has probably caused him to grow eyes in the back of
    his head...
    Now you're thinking like a real Italian - blame the fakking track...
     
    Mark N, Oct 9, 2009
    #15
  16. PaulpULVITZKA

    sturd Guest

    Mark N doesn't get it:
    Running on the curb isn't required to shut the door on somebody.
    You really do need to take a Danny Walker course or something
    as this is a huge gap in your understanding. Get a YSR50 and
    get out to the local bash and crash. Something so you'll start
    understanding a bit of racecraft.

    My 12 year old learned an immense amount at Supercamp
    a couple weeks ago. It was awe inspiring. I wish I had
    12 year old synapses.


    Go fast. Take chances.
    Mike S.
     
    sturd, Oct 9, 2009
    #16
  17. PaulpULVITZKA

    sturd Guest

    Michael Sierchio says:
    Hmmm, my buddy has an RSV1000 he's done three years of
    track days on with no problems. Bar sending it down the
    road and having to fix the scrapes. What do you know that
    makes you think that?


    Go fast. Take chances.
    Mike S.
     
    sturd, Oct 9, 2009
    #17
  18. PaulpULVITZKA

    Dave Guest


    I have an uneasy feeling that Rea is going to factor into the results
    in a negative way. Lately he's been fast enough to be at the front
    and reckless enough to be a danger to everyone around him.

    What I do find interesting is that the last two races are the very
    first that we've seen Spies miss a setup and actually finish a race
    without being competitive. He and his team have been uncanny in their
    ability to nail the setups for tracks he's never seen, but they
    finally missed the mark a couple times right at the end of the season.
    Hopefully that won't be an issue at the final round.
     
    Dave, Oct 9, 2009
    #18
  19. PaulpULVITZKA

    allen Guest

    Do explain - I haven't heard Rea described as "reckless" before.
     
    allen, Oct 9, 2009
    #19
  20. PaulpULVITZKA

    Julian Bond Guest

    WTF are you on about? You really think finishing 4th and 5th at Imola
    was an "interesting strategy" to stop Ducati getting an extra weight
    advantage. You really are so full of shit.
     
    Julian Bond, Oct 9, 2009
    #20
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.