Short version of long story: bike a category D write off (uneconomical to repair, due to cosmetic damage) - i.e. perfeckly rideable, just bits of plastic falling off it and some bent bits sort of thing. Y2K Thundercat (and sorry, there's only one of it) 24K miles. They gave me 2.8K insurance, but want 1.1K if I want to buy it back off them. My questions are: [1] Why should a written off bike be worth eleven hundred quid? [2] What happens to it if I give it to them? (not that I'm emotionally attached to it - I just want to know if it will cost them money to kill it completely or make them money as manky spares) [3] Would any of you lot pay that much for a 4.5 year old write off? [4] How much (seriously) should I put up as a counter offer?