For ukrm fans of Italian motorcycle clothing brands

Discussion in 'UK Motorcycles' started by Paul Varnsverry, Sep 23, 2004.

  1. I have been approached to assist a company that wishes to manufacture
    textile kart racing suits; however, they are required to obtain
    homologation for their products from the International governing body
    - CIK – before they may market them.

    A quick look on the CIK website reveals that the technical
    specification is a copy/paste from the European Standards for
    motorcyclists protective clothing – EN 13595 Parts 1 – 4. Karting
    suits are subjected to the same impact abrasion and impact cut tests,
    and there are two performance levels which are also identical to the
    motorcycle clothing requirements.

    Looking at the list of homologated products, I espied the name
    "Alpinestars", who offer karting suits in both performance level 1 and
    performance level 2 configurations. A quick check on the Alpinestars
    web site brought up images of fabric karting suits with CIK
    homologation. Nothing in the motorcycling section about their bike
    gear being subjected to the same testing and approval process,
    however.

    So, if you want to wear something bearing the Alpinestars brand that
    has been tested and meets the European motorcyclists protective
    clothing standards, the advice seems to be buy one of their fabric
    karting suits!

    Struck me as somewhat surreal!
     
    Paul Varnsverry, Sep 23, 2004
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. Paul Varnsverry

    Slider Guest

    Paul Varnsverry wrote:
    [snip]
    Having slid down a couple of roads and been hit by a car whilst in my
    Alpinestars, I would say that I rate the protective qualities of their
    leathers too.
     
    Slider, Sep 23, 2004
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. I have recently contributed to another thread on Buffalo gloves where
    the matter of quality control amongst motorcycle clothing suppliers is
    aired: seldom, haphazard or non-existent?

    Your suit may have ben a shining example of the brand, or in the
    chaotic circumstances that are a road traffic accident, the forces to
    which your suit was subjected did not exceed its design capabilities.
    I doubt you are too preoccupied with such technicalities, however. :)

    In the one piece suit product test which appeared in the August issue
    of RiDE, the Alpinestars Race Replica suit was the most expensive
    product featured at GBP 1499.95. Despite this lofty price tag, it
    scored "average" in abrasion performance, "below average" in the seam
    burst tests and a poor result in the tear test. Only the Dainese
    T-Bora suit scored lower overall; this despite a 10/10 impact abrasion
    score (but IMHO the test data would have been skewed by the
    performance of the limited surface area titanium components fitted to
    the the shoulder caps).

    RiDE contracts SATRA to perform its laboratory testing, so the methods
    used are those described in the motorcycle clothing standard EN 13595.
    RiDE's presentation of data doesn't compare products with the
    requirements of the standard, but it would be instructive to see the
    raw data and to determine where in the hierarchy stipulated within the
    standard - Level 2 (highest), Level 1 (lowest) or fail - the products
    lie.
     
    Paul Varnsverry, Sep 24, 2004
    #3
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.