Daytona 200

Discussion in 'Motorcycle Racing' started by Dave, Mar 7, 2009.

  1. Dave

    Dave Guest

    [No actual spoilers below]

    Well, the last few laps were exciting, but overall I'd have to say...
    what a fucking disaster!

    For me, running under the lights really didn't add anything at all to
    the show. We've already had MotoGP and F1 under the lights and the
    lighting at Daytona just didn't seem quite as impressive for some
    reason.

    The rolling start was almost as exciting as a box of rocks. I'd say
    it was far more of a loss than a gain for the show. I suppose the one
    thing it did accomplish was to make turn 1 safer since the riders were
    more spread out behind the car than they would have been on the grid.

    The "safety" car is a total disaster too. They don't need it or use
    it anywhere else in the world of motorcycle racing, but those Daytona
    experts know better. The use of the safety car was directly
    responsible for one crash with a red flag and several more near
    crashes.

    Naturally, running under the lights means one more thing that can
    fail. And they did. And the safety car has to come out while they
    work on the lights.

    Then they wave the race leader by the safety car and have to waste
    even more laps trying to get that straightened out. The problem is
    made worse for motorcycles because they don't use radios or have a way
    to communicate complex information to the riders. I was wondering if
    we were going to finish the race under yellow as is common in NASCAR.

    The new competition number system is another disaster. Even the
    announcers are calling riders by the wrong name because they lost
    their usual number this year. In a way I'm glad they let both Ben and
    Jake use #1 though. It wasn't bad since the two bikes are so easy to
    differentiate.

    Then there's the rules confusion. Apparently they changed the
    starting procedure and some riders such as Tommy Hayden don't
    understand what the new procedure is even after reading the rulebook.
    Danny Eslick qualified second for the 200 and wasn't even sure where
    that put him on the grid, "It's good for the ... Buell to be on the
    front row, or however they're doing it." According to Soup there was
    a tussle in the riders meeting but they didn't say what it was about.
    All this hints at the lack of clear communication coming from the new
    regime.

    Finally, Hodgson and Bostrom both point out that a Superpole is only
    interesting as a live event. You need to watch it without already
    knowing the outcome, and just seeing highlights on the TV show won't
    cut it either. Admittedly, I've only seen WSBK Superpole two or three
    times in total and never found it to be all that interesting.

    I'm not so sure I'll even watch the ASB race in two weeks since I
    already know how it plays out. I can avoid the Motorcycle websites
    and spoilers until Tuesday when necessary, but two weeks? No way!
     
    Dave, Mar 7, 2009
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. But, but, it's just like NASCAR, it's got to be more exciting that
    way ;)
    Agreed, and by the looks of it caused the worst injury of the event.
    I'm not so sure they failed. It happen at a convenient time to bunch
    everyone back up for a run to the finish. There seemed to be plenty
    of light despite the two banks going out. It was never mentioned why
    they went out. I assume they got put back on, but there was never any
    mention of that either. Guess it got overlooked with all the
    excitement of the pace car screw up and red flag.
    They would have finished under the yellow if they hadn't red flagged
    it. Then they add insult to injury when they get going under the
    green for the last laps only to cut away to run four or five adds that
    we had already seen a few times in the last hour.
    It's all part of the plan. DMG wants that class to go away. ASB
    makes their chosen class look slow.
     
    Bruce Richmond, Mar 8, 2009
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. Dave

    BillyZoom Guest


    Totaly stupid race format

    I wonder how the potographers dealt with the nighttime shots, the
    pictures in the local Daytona paper online sucked.

    Live timing got stuck on lap 37 for 10-15 minutes, plus ended at lap 55
    (2 laps missing?)

    Pace car bullshit made that race just as boring as the Rolex.

    They broke for commercials with 4 to go via what the announcer said.

    Oh well in 2 weeks real sports car racing starts and the TT is less than
    3 months away + Northwest 200.
     
    BillyZoom, Mar 8, 2009
    #3
  4. Dave

    Julian Bond Guest

    Reading the press conference transcript on Superbikeplanet, it felt like
    race control didn't have a clue what was going on half the time.

    Was talking to another race fan yesterday about all this. The US is such
    a strange mixture looking from the outside. It can produce some of the
    best stuff in the world (if you're prepared to pay for it) And it can be
    extraordinarily professional. But at other times, stuff is built down to
    lowest common denominator and calling the organisation chaotic is an
    understatement. And unfortunately the AMA, Daytona and US bike racing
    seems to fall in the second camp. There's been just too many instances
    of flat out amateurish chaos over the last 20 years for anyone to take
    it seriously any more.

    On pace cars, BSB has been using a pace car for the last 5-8 years. It
    works and everyone understands it. They put a fast car driven
    aggressively out between the leader and the tail-ender. The car has
    flashing lights on it that are turned off during the lap when it comes
    in so the riders know when the race is about to start again. But the
    tracks and races are short enough that there's usually a clear gap
    between first and last. From a spectator's point of view it's better
    than a restart (or three) but it does tend to screw up the result
    especially if somebody has made a clear break or is trying to fight back
    though the field.
     
    Julian Bond, Mar 8, 2009
    #4
  5. Dave

    Will Hartung Guest

    Safety car is always a disaster. Every single time it seems. Two
    problems with the 200. It's the first race of the season, and it's the
    only one of its kind. So it always plays out as if these guys have never
    run a race in their life. There always seems to be some CF that happens.
    I don't understand it.
    But, but BUT they're SUPPOSED to have radios. That's supposed to be one
    of the Big Changes. The change that brings the AMA in to the early 20th
    century.
    Well, speaking of Eslick...

    I don't want to disparage him or his team. I don't really want to
    disparage the Buell, but...

    WTF was a Buell doing on the front row? If the Buell is doing that well
    out the gate with Eslick on it, then that bike is going to be trouble.
    Superpole is fun AT THE TRACK, personally. NASCAR (when I saw it)
    effectively did SuperPole for its qualifying. Even it was mildly
    interesting at the track.

    I watched it "live" on the web.
    Yea 2 weeks is a corker. What a joke.

    For a minute there, I had almost positive thoughts on the TV show.

    See, in 2 weeks, they'll be out here in Fontana. And the (according to
    the Schedule), they're going to run DSB and ASB on Sat, and then again
    on Sunday. 2 races each day. (well I think the kid show runs too
    sometime, I really don't care.)

    Anyway, my thinking was "Ya know, if they were smart, they COULD
    broadcast the 2 SAT races ON Saturday night, and we'd be stuck waiting a
    week for Sundays. But, truth, they can't do any reasonable coverage of
    Daytona and do the 2 Sat races, even in a 3hr show unless they just
    butcher everything. So, once I realized that, I knew I hadn't lost my
    ground. SNAFU maintained control.

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Mar 8, 2009
    #5
  6. Dave

    Will Hartung Guest

    It WAS NASCAR (save, you know, for the TV coverage). All it was missing
    was Ben doing backflips off his Yamaha. How much more NASCAR can you get
    than this?

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Mar 8, 2009
    #6
  7. Dave

    Will Hartung Guest

    The pictures on the TV sucked. They were out of focus half the time.
    Actually, the real problem was the DIRECTION. I dunno who directed the
    show but they were great at showing unimportant stuff on the TV.

    For example, when they came back from break to a full course yellow,
    what did we see? Hayes "in traffic" and the booth chatting up how
    horrible it was. Took them a good several minutes to tell us they were
    even under yellow. Now, if they, you know, came back from break showing
    the safety car, well we'd probably get a clue as spectators.


    Speed does that with WSB too. They somehow think that nobody is going
    anywhere that late in the race.

    The only highlight of the night were the colored lights on the Yamahas.
    Those looked pretty cool. Other than that, meh.

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Mar 8, 2009
    #7
  8. Safety cars are used in World Endurance as well; *two* cars come on to
    the track at the same time, separated by half a lap. This divides the
    field (which can be up to 64 bikes) into two groups, which seems more
    manageable than having one big pack. Riders complain about getting
    stuck behind the "wrong" car sometimes, but by and large it works
    well.

    World Endurance has also been running night races for a long time,
    with all the circuits at least partially lit. In ten years of
    attending every race in the championship, I've never known there to be
    a lighting problem.
     
    Martin Gelder, Mar 8, 2009
    #8
  9. Dave

    Julian Bond Guest

    Has Speed shown the Philip Island WSB and WSS yet? Is it ok if I tell
    you the results? [1]
































    [1]All three races were great and an American won one of them.
     
    Julian Bond, Mar 8, 2009
    #9
  10. Dave

    Will Hartung Guest

    Yea, we got Race 1 on Sunday, and Race 2 and WSS on Tuesday.

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Mar 8, 2009
    #10
  11. Dave

    Julian Bond Guest

    Oh, we're perfectly capable of screwing everything up too. Just wait
    till the Olympics. The marching band will be perfect, everything else
    will be fairly flaky.
    I don't know. Trying to keep a program on schedule with 3 red flags
    sucks as well. I've been at Brands when the WSS race took 3 goes (after
    Chambon deliberately lay on the track, allegedly). Any serious break in
    the program messes everyone up as well. At Cadwell last year when there
    was a 45 minute break while they brought two ambulance helicopters in.
    On balance a pace car probably is preferable to a red flag but it should
    only be used when the alternative is a red flag.

    As for the lighting at Daytona, there was a fire, right? Or was that
    imaginary?
     
    Julian Bond, Mar 8, 2009
    #11
  12. Or should most of incidents be taken care of with a stationary or
    waving yellow in the affected turn, resulting in little or no change
    in the spacing of the field? The first time the pace car was brought
    out it was for a single bike down with rider up and the bike off the
    track. The general rule at national races (including Daytona) used to
    be that if the bike was off the track a stationary yellow was all that
    was put out. Corner workers know when they are in a crash zone and
    keep an eye on what is coming at them.

    Only some of the lights in the chicane went out. There were still
    enough on to keep racing while they got them all back on. At most it
    warrented a waving yellow to prevent passing in that area.

    The red flag only came out due to the crash caused by bringing out the
    pace car. If the pace car wasn't used the race could have run the
    full distance without stopping it. With a pace car they use it in
    situations that don't require it because they see it as less of an
    interruption than stopping the race, and having the bennefit of
    bunching the field back up.
     
    Bruce Richmond, Mar 8, 2009
    #12
  13. Dave

    T3 Guest


    Just got back from clusterfuk '09, so gimmee a little while to kick
    this monumental hangover...
     
    T3, Mar 8, 2009
    #13
  14. Dave

    Dave Guest

    To be fair, I think his point was that I mistakenly said that pace
    cars aren't used in motorcycle racing anywhere else in the world.
    Julian and Martin both pointed out two separate venues where they are.
    I stand corrected.

    However, I think it's still safe to say that a pace car shouldn't be
    used in a one-off event of a larger series. All the unique
    characteristics of Daytona make it the most confusing and downright
    unsafe event of the year. It also seems to be the biggest clusterfuck
    event of the year when it comes to race direction and procedures.
     
    Dave, Mar 8, 2009
    #14
  15. Dave

    Dave Guest

    So they're running ASB and DSB on both days? This means we *should*
    be getting the Saturday races on Saturday evening throughout the
    season but the Sunday races will always be one-week delayed. And
    frankly, we don't even know yet that they'll be able to get the
    Saturday races edited in time for the Saturday evening show so they
    might both be delayed a week. Actually, come to think of it they
    couldn't really show all four races plus tiny-tot highlights in one
    show (plus exciting special guests and late-breaking insider news!!!!)
    They will have to split the Saturday and Sunday races between two
    shows, which works out I guess since they intentionally avoided any
    back-to-back race weekends on the schedule.

    Man this sucks! I've never really cared about races being shown live,
    with all the problems that entails, but I've always wanted them shown
    same-day or at least same-weekend. I fail to see how this "ground
    breaking" new Saturday night show with its week+ delayed races is
    doing *anything* at all positive for the sport.
     
    Dave, Mar 8, 2009
    #15
  16. Dave

    sturd Guest

    Julian Bond posits:
    Yebut. I think AMA is different in that the leaders are lapping
    people after not very many laps, even at Daytona.. So the clear
    break isn't so clear by lap 30 something as happened this time.
    There are all these backmarkers that the pace car has to figure
    out.

    Are they going to use the pace car all year? If so I can't wait for
    Mid-Ohio where the 10th place guy will get lapped twice minimum.
    Will give the new DMG motto - "clusterfucks backwards R us"


    Go fast. Take chances.
    Mike S.
     
    sturd, Mar 9, 2009
    #16
  17. Dave

    Julian Bond Guest

    LOL!

    I really thought the Aprilia RSVs would be faster. I guess the most
    notable thing was that the CBR600s really weren't competitive. And I did
    have to laugh at the same Buell model being up there in both ASB and
    DSB.
     
    Julian Bond, Mar 9, 2009
    #17
  18. Dave

    Julian Bond Guest

    Julian Bond, Mar 9, 2009
    #18
  19. Dave

    T3 Guest

    (Only odd because I rode this year and was waaay too occupied with one
    of the female persuasion..)

    Speedweek 09 started out shakey, had a few "bright spots" and ended
    with a bang, though however you viewed the events the weather was as if
    the chamber of commerce ordered it up, nothing short of spectacular,
    55-75 and not a cloud, much less a rain filled one, to be found..

    A cold front and threat of tornadoes caused the Savannah, Ga. Hot-shoe
    to be cancelled and we understood that, what I couldn't was why the
    B'ville "Shoe" was cancelled the following day(Sunday) and given it has
    always been very well attended I'm still at a loss as to why. The
    Memorial Stadium Shortrack's were again the class of the weeknights,
    well run and pretty much sold out, hat's off to "Wiley" and Kopp for a
    couple of great efforts..

    At the Speedway the Superpoles were pretty cool and actually offered a
    little drama, though for an almost non-existent crowd and if I
    understand it correctly they won't show up on TV for a couple of
    weeks.(WTF is that all about?)
    The ASB race was one of the closest big bike races (brand wise) in some
    time, though Mat still found a way. Damn good race, just waaaay too
    short. He may have been on last years bike, but Pegram, and to some
    extent Hodgy, served notice that things may be a little tougher this
    year for Suz and his "Aussieness." BTW, the Duc is a F'ing rocket-ship
    and had everybody totally covered in the traps.

    The 200 was, for the lack of a better description, a clusterfuk, that
    even running under the lights didn't, or couldn't hide, though TBH it
    did have a fair amount of drama, but when Eslick's Buell/Rotax/H-D went
    south it seemed like the whole race went with it. Guys started running
    into each other, passing under caution, you name it and it probably
    happened somewhere. Obviously, "somebody's" weren't paying attention to
    caution lights, though the "safety car" screw-up and lights burning out
    damn sure didn't help.
    To me, the format Proracing's uses at DIS needs to be re-thought, why
    doesn't ASB do the 200? At one time tires were an issue and given the
    speed at DIS a critical one too, but with night racing on production
    equipment, why the f*ck not? Another qualm I have is why so many bikes?
    There had to be 70, or so and a lot of those guys just run this one
    race so they don't have a bunch of experience, nor are they likely to
    ever get much of DMG's Nasty Car ways, so why? Make no mistake DIS and
    ProRacing dodged a couple huge bullets Friday night in the form of
    600cc rockets that came unbelievably close to making the 200 more like
    pavement bowling than a motorcycle race. No one needs that shit, trim
    and educate the field!

    SX was awesome and while it's not my chosen brand of M/C racing I can
    not diminish it's impact and how well they put on the show. Very well
    done and Kudos' to Reed for an outstanding performance running down
    J-Law for the W, as well as my boy Davi for snatching third..

    I had lil' Red in tow this year and broke all kinds of 'Tona rules, we
    rode and stayed there and yes, actually went downtown,(just once;-)
    sorta all the stuff I learned a long time ago that's not really in your
    best interest to do and while we had a good time and no one we knew
    went to jail I'm sorry to report, Daytona, east of the speedway is
    still comes off like a sleazy shithole, sorta' like a cross between a
    rodeo and Thunderdome with some blue-hairs thrown in for sport..

    A week of much needed (liver) rest and we're off to Gatorland for the
    Nationals, C'ya there...
     
    T3, Mar 9, 2009
    #19
  20. Dave

    sturd Guest

    sturd, Mar 13, 2009
    #20
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.