As the worm turns..

Discussion in 'Motorcycle Racing' started by T3, Jul 3, 2008.

  1. T3

    T3 Guest

    T3, Jul 3, 2008
    #1
    1. Advertisements

  2. T3

    Mark N Guest

    Perhaps more like someone actually started listening, that somebody
    being DMG, of course. Probably the result of the MIC announcement, the
    positions being taken by Miller, Laguna and perhaps other tracks, and
    the fan outrage in general. What would be really interesting to know
    is if any change forthcoming is the result of Jimmy France getting
    directly involved, banging on his employees and shouting, "What the
    hell are you guys doing?!"...

    Anyway, the devil is in the details, as you say, and there are many
    more questions than answers still. So is this the latest version of
    Literbike, isolate the factory teams and try to keep the rest out - no
    purse or mandatory contingencies, etc.? Does the latest rumor about a
    1000 SStock class ("American SB") still stand, and is GSB ("Genuine
    SB") just a 09-10 stop-gap, do they switch if the FIM's SB dumb-down
    at the national and perhaps world level starts to build momentum? Or
    do they add a 600 SSt class instead, since so much momentum seemed to
    have been behind the removal of AMA SSt? Or are we still at two
    classes?

    In any case, we are where we should have been 3-4 months ago, DMG
    having wasted all that time and created all that aggrevation for
    everyone for essentially nothing. At least everyone learned that these
    guys are not to be trusted - with anything.

    Now what about that riding in the rain at all road courses?
     
    Mark N, Jul 3, 2008
    #2
    1. Advertisements

  3. T3

    Will Hartung Guest

    Of course this really begs the question: Why not just run the '09/'10
    AMA rules they had already set up and agreed to. Run 'em for two years,
    then pull the rug out from under them. No reason to adopt something like
    WSBK when they already have a rules package. Nothing to negotiate any
    more. Run '09, start talking new rules winter of '09, run '10 and change
    them to whatever in '11.

    What a waste of time.

    And the other key, if adopted as rumored, it's a complete cave for DMG.
    This whole experience has been very expensive for them in terms of good
    will and respect, from everyone. Lot of folks had a lot of high hopes
    coming in to this, and most of that has been shattered, even if they're
    "seeing the light". They may be seeing the light, but we have all seen
    them "in the light", and didn't necessarily like what we saw.

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Jul 4, 2008
    #3
  4. T3

    Julian Bond Guest

    "Just run FIM rules" Is that an option? With BSB losing the plot
    somewhat over the rules, having the USA, UK and WSB all use the same
    rule set makes some sense. Perhaps then we'd get back to having wild
    cards in the WSB races.

    And on that several teams in BSB have said they won't be doing wild
    cards because they don't have FIM spec engines and can't afford to
    produce them for one/two races.
     
    Julian Bond, Jul 4, 2008
    #4
  5. T3

    Will Hartung Guest

    True, but if adopted it's an about face on DMGs "we're doing this, you
    all can get stuffed" attitude. Maybe it's just perception, but the
    impression we're getting (granted from the "injured" parties) was
    basically there was no room for the 1000's at all, then the contrived
    "You want, 1000's, you got 1000's" in LOLBike that the factories balked on.

    If the vision was to get the factories out of racing, it's either
    working very well, or not working at all. It seems DMG felt that the
    factories would buckle instead of posturing to pull out, if not outright
    fork a new series. The "We're the only game in town, you have to deal
    with us" replied with a "Well, no, actually, we don't."

    This late in the game, save for a couple of random reader letters, I
    haven't seen a positive article on DMG anywhere. Now we're late in the
    year, we're already hearing about Miller potentially culling the AMA
    from their WSB round, and everything is confusion.

    All because they came in cocksure and blinded with their vision,
    assuming all concerned would grin an bear it.

    Now we see that's not that case, and that folks are willing to sacrifice
    the bathwater and the baby.

    So, adopting WSB, I think, is mud in their visionary eye. As you say, it
    doesn't fix the primary complaint about the series -- expense and
    unobtainium. It's a complete concession to the factories, even if it's a
    "Secondary series".

    I like your idea of DSB being a "one stop mini endurance", that sets it
    apart, it's not TOO long, and it adds in all the elements they want to
    the mix. I can't see it running twice a weekend, tho, but, frankly, I
    can't fathom seeing the first event on Saturday if I have to endure a
    Moto-ST race to get there. The Moto-ST race, frankly, turns the whole
    thing in to a one day event for me.

    That doesn't affect TV, mind, but...

    If they ran "FSB" twice, 1pm Saturday followed by Moto-ST, and 3pm
    Sunday, following Red Bull and DSB, then I can see going both days. I
    can come for qualifying, practice, the FSB race, and then leave, maybe
    catching a bit of Moto-ST, or whatever. Then I can come back on Sunday
    for the 3 other races.

    That's a decent value to me.

    Then, if their vision works out, in two years they can demote FSB to
    Sunday, maybe swap back "new DSB Sprint edition" for the two races, and
    slowly get back to their promised land. But at least it's transitionary,
    and gives time for everyone to work things out and get to know one
    another than what is happening right now.

    Right now the clock is ticking, and we don't have rules, we don't have a
    spec tire vendor (that we know of), certainly no testing, and we have
    factories and tracks talking about pulling out completely.

    Of course, the real crux of this, as a spectator and remote observer,
    we're not supposed to know about ANY of this. It's all supposed to be
    done in smoked filled rooms. Seems to me, after the first release, every
    other thing we've heard from DMG is reaction or rumor (save the "race in
    the rain for cash and prizes" comments). But, as far as the new series,
    they haven't said much "officially". It's all either second hand or
    reactions to "leaks".

    But what we have heard is all has been "from the throne", from the
    Dictator, running his dictatorship. From the lorded over peoples, all we
    hear is dissent and off with his head.

    If DMG accepts the WSB proposal, it goes in the face of the
    dictatorship, it ruins, for the time being, the grand scheme. Everything
    I've heard from DMG has been, essentially, little more than contempt for
    what we have now. If they accept the WSB proposal, they'll be holding
    their nose doing it. "We'll do it, but under protest". They may talk
    compromise, but it sure doesn't come well from their statements and
    posturing. There's no sincerity here.

    That will mean, even if adopted, FSB will be the red headed black sheep
    step child, and likely shown the door as soon as practical, and perhaps
    actively undermined. It goes against, to the core, the philosophy of
    what DMG is trying to do. But, apparently, they're not strong enough
    that they think they can let the factories just walk. They want to tell
    them to get stuffed, but seem, so far, to lack the willpower to stick to
    their guns, pushing their vision through the throngs assembled outside
    with torches and pitchforks.

    The letter in Soup from Kawasaki (I think it was Soup, maybe RRW,
    anyway) was interesting. On the one hand he says they like racing,
    they're committed to racing, racing is important to them. But on the
    other he commented that he can see the program being removed completely,
    like back in '83 and Muzzy was finally able to get them to recreate the
    program in '88.

    That's the consequence, I think, if DMG pushes it and the factories
    walk. It's very hard to see a second series succeed, and it's easy to
    see the factories go on hiatus for several years. Maybe in 5 years, DMG
    will want them back, and will have to go back knocking on their doors.
    Or, perhaps the factories will be knocking on DMGs door. Kind of depends
    on the success of the series.

    But, frankly, I don't see a big jump in market share for the Euro
    companies just because their bikes might actually be seen on TV in DMG
    unless they start backing it with major media investments. I think that
    Aprilla, KTM, Triumph, or BMW or whoever can, today, right now, sponsor
    an AMA event, by program space, and run ads on TV with the race
    broadcasts, even if their bikes aren't running in the race. The
    demographic is already watching the race.

    Basically, I don't think the Euro companies need to actually field a
    team, in ANY series, to leverage the media opportunities racing provides
    today. Can't complain about Suzuki winning a race that your bike isn't
    in. Sell a cruiser, the KTM Adventure, or some other non-race bike.

    Hell, Miller was sponsored by some skin care thing...they didn't race
    anything!

    So, anyway, kind of rambling.

    I don't know what's going to happen. I'm cynical about the whole thing,
    and even if we went '09 AMA rules, with the current teams, even the
    current classes, the whole thing has left such a bad taste in my mouth,
    I don't know why I should patronize this new organization at all.
    They're doing nothing to earn it in my book.


    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Jul 5, 2008
    #5
  6. T3

    Julian Bond Guest

    Pirelli spec tyres everywhere? I was thinking about BSB wild cards in
    the UK WSB rounds (and WSB wild cards in BSB rounds) but of course the
    USA has a different tyre manufacturer for it's one tyre supplier.
    For 2009 and 2010, it's not just the 1098R. But also the Aprilia RSV4
    and KTM RC8. The simple solution to the 1098R is to push up the
    homologation numbers. Which is happening in WSB. Which probably means a
    1098SP with price and components pitched half way between the S and R.
    But Ducati's a big company now and should Aprilia and KTM be held to the
    same standard? Clearly, Ducati will produce a bike to the rules and do
    their damndest (like Honda) to get the rules adjusted to their bike. But
    one of the problems in SBK has always been how to deal with the smaller
    factories.
     
    Julian Bond, Jul 5, 2008
    #6
  7. T3

    T3 Guest

    I think before giving not enough/too much credit to any one group, or
    voice you might want to consider how hard fuel prices are impacting
    every aspect of our economy. I'm sure DMG knows, or will have a pretty
    good idea after this evening..

    http://www.local6.com/news/16789067/detail.html

    There was quite a discussion back at Daytona about how DMG would
    manifest themselves and their new way, with us old timer's split on
    whether they'd ease US racing into their vision, or force feed it. Now
    it looks like maybe they're unwilling to go the draconian route,(at
    this time) though I don't believe it has much to do with anything
    beyond the economy, as every penny gas rises removes $'s from the
    equation and running die-hard folks off at this time with their new
    vision isn't fiscally smart and when it comes to $'s the guys aren't
    anything, but smart..

    Is the Nip OEM war over? Oh hell no! It looks it's just on the back
    burner for a while, that's all..

    IF, and it's a pretty big if right now, they actually do proceed with a
    WSB thing I'd expect something to go, be it ST, or most likely the
    SStock type litres, as there just isn't enough time in the weekend, or
    on Sunday for that matter...
    Divide and conquer, at it's finest too..
    I think they want only DSB on Sunday, I also believe they'll eventually
    (if not sooner) make those races 100 miles, or so, with at least one
    pit stop too..
    See above..
    No, they've been too busy covering their collective asses and trying
    figure out this new regime, the latter I can understand, the former, I
    do not..

    I wouldn't go that far at all..
    Though I would not bet against that..
    "Someone" said it's best to wait until a rule book is printed and that
    most of what we see and read until then is posturing and little more..
    The MIC thing was a bluff, plain and simple, at least I hope it was,
    because the last thing any of us should want is some west coast Jap SB
    series and all the blowback that will come from that..
    Let's review. Money and hammers? If hammers means influence at every
    venue in this country and money meaning, well, boatloads of buck$, I
    dunno 'bout you, but I'm thinkin' I'm going with the rich carpenter.
    And speaking of rich, when is France gonna write the check, I mean
    c'mon, it's been what, 4 month's? Time to pony up some bucks I would
    think...

    You see, that's the part I don't get, especially from someone that
    professes love for the sport..
    Shit, you're just dreamin' again, damn, and I thought you were
    conscious, oh well...


    I hope everyone had a safe and fun 4th (Limey azzkickin' holiday) I'm
    pretty sure we did, at least AFAIK we didn't burn anything down and no
    one went to the ER, or, more importantly, has called about bail...
     
    T3, Jul 5, 2008
    #7
  8. T3

    Julian Bond Guest

    Just saying is all. And those Pirellis really aren't as bad as they
    were. ISTR Pirelli won Daytona 200 this year (not superbike of course)?
    Or am I imagining that?
    Hmmm. I don't know the answer to that. When the numbers increase to 3000
    in a year, is the old homologation at 150, 500, 1000 or whatever still
    valid?
    KTM possibly on total numbers, probably not on total revenue. Although
    they are expanding fast and if they haven't already passed Ducati on
    world sales they may well soon.

    Aprilia as a factory in it's own right, or as part of Piaggio? Scooters
    or just road motorcycles?
    Yes. And Honda is the uncontested master at manipulating the regulatory
    bodies and dominating the MSMA.
    It's just another aspect of how difficult it is to frame rules for a
    road bike based series. If you push up the homologation numbers
    requirement, especially if you make it regional, you make it hard for a
    smaller, new manufacturer or new model to be eligible. So, it might be
    good for the series and the entertainment if, say, KTM ran a factory
    RC8. But it may be completely unreasonable to ask KTM to register 1000
    of them in the USA whereas Honda might well register 10 times that in
    total number of Fireblades. But if you make concessions for the smaller
    models, the smaller factories will exploit that.

    BTW. Do DGM, really need the factories to homologate the bikes? How does
    that work exactly?
     
    Julian Bond, Jul 6, 2008
    #8
  9. T3

    T3 Guest

    (typing slow, just for you)
    I imagine DMG knew, or at least expected to take a hit with the
    "purist's" on their DSB only thrust and they probably thought they
    could lessen the pain at the gate with new fans. You with me? Okay, now
    comes a shit box economy with fuel prices thru the roof and still
    climbing, so it isn't very $mart to run off the die-hard fans in the
    midst of a recession, is it? Remember, these guys have to sell this
    product to tracks and IIRC track guys like to see folks coming thru
    their gates and while there might be a few new people, it's those old
    ones that are bankable. So, maybe it's not a good idea to run them off
    right now, get my drift?
    Maybe had you'd been a little less busy manufacturing venom and
    actually paying attention you would've noticed when I brought the
    economy angile up the first few times, but apparently you were too busy
    on some whacky-ass nazi racist rant to notice, though to me it's just
    another example of you missing important pieces of the puzzle because
    you were running around ala Chicken Little..
    A war of control, a long overdue one at that. Heh, in reality that
    war's probably already over, and it's what the peace is going to look
    like that's really the question..
    You can picture what you want, I think they did a remarkable job
    splitting a block that really had never split before and regardless
    whether you, or I like the eventual outcome, it's hard for me not to
    give kudo's on what looks like a well played gem..
    One would sure think so, but I'll be dammed if I can come up with much
    more at this time..
    Wait a second, didn't they go out west just to do that? If what I read
    was half-way correct they were pretty much shown the door by everyone,
    but Yam. So, saying they haven't reached out is BS..
    Speak for yourself..
    Good, or bad, no matter, it's a thing I have absolutely no control
    over. So why get all bent out of shape?
    It most certainly was not! You're the Google guy, aren't you? Go check
    if you want just be careful reading that stuff, you might actually
    learn something..
    And not just by them either, EVERYBODY has something to lose, or gain
    in this deal, that you either refuse, or are unable to see that amazes
    me..
    I don't know if blame's the word I would use, but I do feel they're a
    little tardy..
    The alternative series is a pipe dream and it's hard for me not to
    think that if DMG is willing to spend the money their vision will be
    the way of the future. My question at this point(economy) is if they
    see enough return, or how quickly that return comes to justify spending
    a boatload of bucks to bring US M/C racing into the "bigs."

    Let's review, okay? If, by some wild ass chance there was to be another
    series it would consist of what, 3 Japanese OEM's, right? And it would
    be centered on the west coast, right? Hence the west coast Jap SB
    series. I dunno what they call that out there, but around here it's
    called accuracy without a bunch of bullshit!
    Somebody needs to pinch you, or somethin', 'cause you're definitely
    dreamin'! Jeeze, do you make this shit up yourself, dood, get real...
    You really, really need to rethink that..
    The economy could be dragging AMA's payday down in the toilet as it
    goes, but 120+ days to close this deal? Hmm, France handshake or no, if
    I were the Dinger I'd prolly be a little nervous of late..
    I think you might need to re-evaluate what exactly the old AMA
    Proracing was, as using it for foundation to structure such an analogy
    is the same as building a house of cards..
    Chicken kick if I recall correctly, shame too. Shame that camera was
    right there..
    Really? Tell me somethin' straight okay? No bullshit, you equate what
    happened to Edmondson the same as (yer boi) Fania getting a well
    deserved, though unfortunately very public bitch kick? I mean, that
    would soo over the top whacky and this on a bar you've previously set
    so high! WOW!!!
    Yada, yada, yada.. What exactly are you tryin' to tell me here?
    We can conclude? Let me tell you somethin' Bubba, "We" don't come to
    conclusion's just from what's read on the web, obviously "you" do,
    however, "I" try pretty hard not to. Heheh, good thing too, otherwise
    I'd have shined your sorry ass on years ago...
     
    T3, Jul 6, 2008
    #9
  10. T3

    Julian Bond Guest

    Or DGM could just say if it looks like a duck, we say it is a duck. So
    they say a Buell 1125R is allowed to race and they obtain one copy to
    use as a reference. How does anyone challenge that? Or they could piggy
    back onto the FIM homologation by saying bikes can only race if the same
    model has been homologated by them. ISTM the problem is not in stating
    the models, it's with comparing the race bike with some standard after
    the race.

    But then haven't DGM also said that there would be a homologated race
    kit and race parts and it's never been clear exactly who would produce
    those and how they would be approved.
     
    Julian Bond, Jul 6, 2008
    #10
  11. T3

    sturd Guest

    Julian Bond asks:
    No, you're not imagining that. They won in '07 with Rapp, then
    again in '08 with Davies though Davies finished second on
    track behind an illegal Honda that Hayes was riding .


    Go fast. Take chances.
    Mike S.
     
    sturd, Jul 7, 2008
    #11
  12. T3

    Will Hartung Guest

    Yes, they won in '07 and '08 much like Cory West got 3rd in SSport
    instead of Blake Young at Miller. A win is a win, and the record books
    don't like, but, there were "circumstances".

    All of the Hondas imploded in both races, save for Hayes disqualified
    Honda this year. The Hondas have dominated FX the past two years, over
    the Attack team.

    Now whether that's because they run Hondas, or because they run Dunlops,
    I don't think it's fair to say. But, in any case, whatever they're
    doing, the Pirelli's aren't able to close the gap.

    In SStock, the Pirelli's actually seem to make a good fight of it.
    Taking a close second at Daytona, really distant 3rd (20s down) in
    Barber, close 3rd at Fontana, and they won at Road America.

    But that's the only series we see much of them in, at least at the top
    end of the bracket.

    Regards,

    Will Hartung
     
    Will Hartung, Jul 7, 2008
    #12
  13. T3

    Dave Guest

    Perhaps the most interesting perspective is that of Geoff May having
    switched from Emgo/Pirelli to Jordan/Dunlop this year. No one will
    ask him straight out on TV but the tidbits he's dropped make me think
    the Pirelli's are very good for the first third or so of the race, but
    they drop off significantly for the last third whereas the Dunlops
    keep sticking. That would seem to jive with the results of the past
    couple years where the Emgo guys were always battling hard at the
    front in the beginning but were rarely around at the end.
     
    Dave, Jul 7, 2008
    #13
  14. T3

    T3 Guest

    I'm saying they're smart when it comes to making money and with our
    economy in full-on nosedive I can understand why they may have backed
    off a little, *IF* in fact that's what the rumored WSB package is
    about..
    I recall saying three things in particular, 1. They own it and will do
    as they see fit. 2. Don't get all worked up until you see a rule book
    and thirdly, hold on, it's gonna be a rocky ride and as yet I haven't
    seen, or heard ANYTHING to alter that view..
    Monopoly's in general suk ass, though sometimes things are sooo screwed
    up it takes a firm hand to clean up and clean out the crap that's been
    allowed to pile-up over the years..

    Oh really? You might want to check WSB and it's recent history..
    Classic stuff too..
    So, they get what they want and still aren't happy? I look for somebody
    not to like it and still want the original '09 rules, then it'll be
    very interesting to see if DMG allows it. My take? Nada..
    Maybe they "don't even care" beyond DSB and ST..
    Then why did they bother making the trip? Hell, they could've Fed Ex'd
    their DSB rules and been done with 'um..

    WTF, you guys don't have phones and e-mail out there? I'm pretty sure
    they do on Speedway Blvd..
    Yeah, the table and all the shit they stack on it too..
    Ah yes, the harbingers of doom, luv those guys.. So fuckin' what??
    Reality my friend, you might want to check it out sometime..
    There's nothing real as yet, it's ALL posturing!
    You know me, always polite..
    Umm, because you'd have to be high to really believe it's possible?
    Influence is a lot like money, it's only bad when you don't have any
    and trust me on this, they're not gonna run out of either! As far as
    Speed goes, they may have a much larger fish on the hook, at least
    that's a recent rumor..
    Heh, now that I'd pay to see!
    Can I get a hit of whatever it is you've got in that pipe? It must be
    the good shit!
    Well, there ya' go..
    That was MY feelings at Daytona, there were others that believed DMG
    would just throw down their vision and say, "our way, or the hi-way"
    and be done with it..
    When it comes to racing in this country, NO ONE can do what these guys
    are capable of. That's not an endorsement Mark, it's a fact of life..
    Miller runs Nascar and Grand Am, do you think for one second he'd
    jeopardize those paydays for some Jap OEM's? I do not. 'Guna? Who
    knows..
    Heh, not as long as the one we're hopefully fixin' to end on Nov.. (I
    didn't believe it was possible to despise an administration more than
    Nixon's, but these creep's are exponentially worse..)
    WTF have they done? Besides all the hot air (on all sides) I haven't
    seen them do much beyond DQ'ing a few guys. For Christ's sake, give 'um
    some time and I'm fairly sure you'll find legitimate reasons to hate
    them..
    Abrams, a Honda shill, big whoop there, NOT!!
    'Ya know what? I'm likin' the guy more and more all the time!
    Too tired..
    You mean the WORLD CENTER OF RACING? (ouch!;-)

    A campfire down here in July? Not a chance, waaaay too many 'skeetrz...
     
    T3, Jul 7, 2008
    #14
  15. T3

    Julian Bond Guest

    Yup. That's what I was thinking of. And I don't understand how it could
    work or be enforced. Even with something as simple as brake pads.
     
    Julian Bond, Jul 8, 2008
    #15
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.